Crypto on a Foreign Exchange: FBAR and Form 8938
A foreign account holding only virtual currency is not reportable on the FBAR under FinCEN Notice 2020-2, and the rule change that notice announced does not appear in the current eCFR or in any Federal Register document found. Form 8938 is different: its form, instructions and IRS question-and-answer page do not mention crypto at all.
That gap is why this topic is so confusing. Three filings get blurred together, and they run on three separate tests. The FBAR starts at $10,000 in aggregate foreign account value at any time in the year. Form 8938 starts at $50,000 on the last day of the year for an unmarried filer living in the United States, and at $200,000 for one living abroad. The Form 1040 digital asset question has no dollar threshold and does not ask where anything is held. A person can owe none, one, two or all three, and an answer on one form does not settle the others.
Three Forms, Three Different Questions
The FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) is a Bank Secrecy Act report filed with the Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, not with the IRS and not with a tax return. Form 8938 is an income tax form, attached to the annual return. The digital asset question is one line on page 1 of Form 1040. Each asks a different thing, as the IRS pages and form instructions describe.
| FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) | Form 8938 | Form 1040 digital asset question | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it asks | Do you have a financial interest in or signature authority over foreign financial accounts worth more than $10,000 combined at any time in the calendar year? | Do your specified foreign financial assets exceed the threshold for your filing status and residence? | Did you receive digital assets as a reward, award or payment, or sell, exchange or otherwise dispose of one, during the year? |
| Where "foreign" matters | The account is located outside the United States | The financial account is maintained by a foreign financial institution, or a non-account asset is foreign | It is not asked |
| What gets reported | Each account, with its maximum value | Each account or asset, with its maximum value | Yes or No |
| Filed with | FinCEN, electronically through the BSA E-Filing System; never attached to the tax return | The IRS, attached to the annual return | The IRS, on the return |
| Due | April 15 after the calendar year, with an automatic extension to October 15 | The due date of the return, including extensions | The due date of the return, including extensions |
Sources: IRS "Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)" page (reviewed July 30, 2026), IRS "Comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements" (reviewed September 19, 2026), Instructions for Form 8938 (Rev. November 2021), 2025 Form 1040. Checked November 3, 2026.
The IRS comparison page shows how differently the first two tests treat the same account. A financial account held at a foreign branch of a U.S. financial institution is a No for Form 8938 and a Yes for the FBAR. An account at a U.S. branch of a foreign financial institution is a No for both. The FBAR looks at where the account sits, and Form 8938 looks at whether the institution is foreign. An online exchange with no branch in any country fits neither test comfortably, and nothing in the documents checked says how to place it. That is the first of several points covered below as open.
What FinCEN Notice 2020-2 Says, in Full
FinCEN lists the notice on its FBAR page as "FBAR Filing Requirement for Virtual Currency (12/31/2020)". Its operative text is one paragraph, and it is short enough to quote complete:
"Currently, the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) regulations do not define a foreign account holding virtual currency as a type of reportable account. (See 31 CFR 1010.350(c)). For that reason, at this time, a foreign account holding virtual currency is not reportable on the FBAR (unless it is a reportable account under 31 C.F.R. 1010.350 because it holds reportable assets besides virtual currency). However, FinCEN intends to propose to amend the regulations implementing the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) regarding reports of foreign financial accounts (FBAR) to include virtual currency as a type of reportable account under 31 CFR 1010.350."
Four things follow from the text itself.
First, the conclusion rests on the regulation, not on a policy choice. The notice says the FBAR regulations "do not define a foreign account holding virtual currency as a type of reportable account", and so the account is not reportable. The definition in 31 CFR 1010.350(c) lists three categories: a bank account ("a savings deposit, demand deposit, checking, or any other account maintained with a person engaged in the business of banking"), a securities account ("an account with a person engaged in the business of buying, selling, holding or trading stock or other securities"), and an "other financial account", which covers deposit-taking agencies, cash-value insurance or annuity policies, accounts with futures or options brokers, and mutual funds or similar pooled funds. Virtual currency is not in any of the three.
Second, the phrase "at this time" is the notice's own, and the notice is a statement of intent. It sets no date for the proposal it announces.
Third, the parenthetical is a real exception. An account that "holds reportable assets besides virtual currency" is reportable under the existing rule. An account at a foreign bank that holds euros and also offers custody of bitcoin is, on that wording, a bank account with a cash balance. Case 3 below works through that arithmetic.
Fourth, the IRS has repeated the position. IRS Publication 5569, the FBAR Reference Guide (Rev. 3-2022), gives this as an example under "Financial Account": "A foreign account holding virtual currency is not reportable on the FBAR (unless it's a reportable account under 31 C.F.R. 1010.350 because it holds reportable assets besides virtual currency). These funds aren't reportable at this time, per FBAR regulations issued by FinCEN February 24, 2011, but FinCEN Notice 2020-2 indicates FinCEN's intention to propose amending the regulations to include virtual currency as a type of reportable account under 31 CFR 1010.350." The IRS digital assets page, reviewed September 2, 2026, still lists the notice among its related resources.
Was the FBAR Amendment Ever Proposed or Finalized?
The notice promised a proposal. The question for a reader today is whether anything followed, and the answer from the primary sources is that nothing has been located. The checks behind that statement, each run on November 3, 2026, were these.
Current regulation text. The eCFR text of 31 CFR 1010.350, taken from Title 31 as current through October 30, 2026, has no category for virtual currency, digital assets or crypto. Its source note ends "76 FR 10245, Feb. 24, 2011, as amended at 76 FR 37000, June 24, 2011". Paragraph (c) still has the three categories described above.
Federal Register search. A search of Federal Register documents from FinCEN containing the phrase "foreign financial accounts" returned thirteen documents, dated from 2004 to 2023. Nine concern the FBAR directly: information-collection notices (2004, 2013, 2018, 2020, 2023), the 2011 final rule and its correction, a proposed rule published March 10, 2016, and a final rule on civil penalties published December 23, 2021. The other four are the 2008 proposed and 2010 final rules titled "Transfer and Reorganization of Bank Secrecy Act Regulations" and two beneficial ownership rulemakings published December 16, 2022 and December 22, 2023. Adding the phrase "virtual currency" to the same search returned no documents. A second search, for "FinCEN Form 114", found a further information-collection notice, published March 29, 2024. None of these documents adds virtual currency to the reportable account types. The March 2024 notice contains no mention of virtual currency, digital assets or crypto.
A third search, for "FBAR" together with "virtual currency" across every agency, returned five documents: FinCEN's April 2026 proposed rule on stablecoin issuer compliance programs, FinCEN's April 2026 whistleblower proposal, a December 2014 final rule on reporting of specified foreign financial assets, and the introductions to the Fall 2021 and Fall 2022 Unified Agenda. The stablecoin proposal does not mention the FBAR. The whistleblower proposal mentions FBAR only to describe the IRS's enforcement authority under 31 CFR 1010.810. The FBAR entry in each of the two agenda introductions describes a pending amendment, and the changes it describes concern "signature or other authority" and "special rules", with no reference to virtual currency.
The agencies' own pages. FinCEN's FBAR page still lists the notice, dated 12/31/2020, as its virtual currency item. The IRS FBAR page, reviewed July 30, 2026, does not mention virtual currency. The IRS Form 8938 page, reviewed August 3, 2026, says under recent developments: "None at this time."
The October 5, 2026 FinCEN release. On that date FinCEN announced it was "withdrawing the following proposed rules that would have imposed certain regulatory requirements on financial institutions related to certain digital assets, specifically convertible virtual currencies". There were two. One was a proposal for recordkeeping, verification and reporting on certain transactions involving convertible virtual currency and unhosted wallets, published at 85 FR 83840 on December 23, 2020, eight days before Notice 2020-2. The other was a special measure on convertible virtual currency mixing, published at 88 FR 72701 on October 23, 2023. The matching Federal Register withdrawals, documents 2026-20430 and 2026-20429, were published October 6, 2026. The release does not mention the FBAR, and neither does the text of either withdrawal. Those two proposals were about transaction-level recordkeeping and reporting by financial institutions; the FBAR notice is about accounts that account holders report. The withdrawals do not repeal, replace or confirm Notice 2020-2.
Where that leaves the status. As of November 3, 2026, the position stated in Notice 2020-2 and restated in Publication 5569 has not been changed by any proposed or final rule found in the sources listed. The newest dated sources checked on this point are the eCFR (current through October 30, 2026), the Federal Register withdrawals of October 6, 2026, and the IRS digital assets page (reviewed September 2, 2026). The word "found" is doing real work: this is a search of the official sources, and a rule that FinCEN issues tomorrow would change the answer. The notice says FinCEN intends to propose a change, and nothing checked shows that it has, or that it has abandoned the idea. Both "still coming" and "quietly dropped" are readings the documents do not support.
Form 8938: The Thresholds, Computed
Form 8938 is the filing with a published dollar ladder. Per the Instructions for Form 8938 (Rev. November 2021), the reporting threshold depends on whether you are married and file jointly and whether you live inside or outside the United States. A threshold is met if the total value of specified foreign financial assets is more than the first figure on the last day of the tax year, or more than the second figure at any time during the year.
| Filer | More than, last day of the tax year | More than, at any time during the year |
|---|---|---|
| Unmarried, lives in the United States | $50,000 | $75,000 |
| Married filing jointly, lives in the United States | $100,000 | $150,000 |
| Married filing separately, lives in the United States | $50,000 | $75,000 |
| Unmarried, lives abroad | $200,000 | $300,000 |
| Married filing jointly, lives abroad | $400,000 | $600,000 |
| Married filing separately, lives abroad | $200,000 | $300,000 |
Source: Instructions for Form 8938 (Rev. November 2021), "Types of Reporting Thresholds". Specified domestic entities use $50,000 and $75,000. The IRS Form 8938 page, reviewed August 3, 2026, lists this as the current revision. Checked November 3, 2026.
Three details change how the table is applied.
Living abroad has its own test. The higher figures apply to a taxpayer whose tax home is in a foreign country and who meets a presence abroad test. The instructions give two: a U.S. citizen who has been a bona fide resident of a foreign country or countries for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year, or a U.S. citizen or resident present in a foreign country or countries at least 330 full days during any period of 12 consecutive months that ends in the tax year being reported.
The two tests are alternatives. An unmarried filer in the United States with $41,000 at year-end who briefly held $80,000 in the middle of the year crosses the second line, because $80,000 is more than $75,000, even though the year-end figure is under $50,000. The instructions' own Example 3 makes the same point: a person who sold their only specified foreign financial asset on October 15 at $125,000 must file, because the value was more than $75,000 at a time during the year.
Joint assets are counted once or in half. On a joint return, an asset owned jointly with a spouse is included once. On separate returns, a spouse who is also a specified individual includes one-half. Someone other than a spouse includes the entire value.
Valuation has its own rules. The instructions say to report the maximum value during the year of each specified foreign financial asset. For accounts, they add: "You may rely on periodic account statements for the tax year to report a financial account's maximum value unless you know or have reason to know based on readily accessible information that the statements do not reflect a reasonable estimate of the maximum account value during the tax year." They also say: "If you have an interest in a financial account that holds specified foreign financial assets, you do not have to report the assets held in the account." The account is the reportable item, not its contents.
What Counts as a Specified Foreign Financial Asset
The instructions sort specified foreign financial assets into two groups. The first is "financial accounts maintained by a foreign financial institution". The second is a list of foreign financial assets held for investment and not held in an account at a financial institution: stock or securities issued by someone who is not a U.S. person, any interest in a foreign entity, and "any financial instrument or contract that has an issuer or counterparty that is not a U.S. person".
A financial account is defined as "any depository or custodial account (under Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(1)(i) or (ii)) maintained by a foreign financial institution", plus certain equity or debt interests in such an institution and cash-value insurance or annuity contracts. A foreign financial institution is, "in most cases", a non-U.S. financial institution that does one or more of three things: it "accepts deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business", it "holds financial assets for the account of others as a substantial part of its business", or it "is engaged (or holds itself out as being engaged) primarily in the business of investing, reinvesting, or trading in securities, partnership interests, commodities, or any interest (including a futures or forward contract or option) in such securities, partnership interests, or commodities".
Form 8938 itself asks the filer to check "Deposit" or "Custodial" for each account in Part V, and the instructions say for line 20 to "indicate if this is a depository or a custodial account". The regulation behind the custodial label, 26 CFR 1.1471-5(b)(3)(ii), reads: "The term custodial account means an arrangement for holding a financial instrument, contract, or investment (including, but not limited to, a share of stock in a corporation, a note, bond, debenture, or other evidence of indebtedness, a currency or commodity transaction, a credit default swap, a swap based upon a nonfinancial index, a notional principal contract as defined in § 1.446-3(c), an insurance or annuity contract, and any option or other derivative instrument) for the benefit of another person."
Here is the gap. The Form 8938, its instructions, the IRS question-and-answer page on Form 8938 (reviewed August 17, 2026), the IRS comparison table, and 26 CFR 1.1471-5 as current through October 30, 2026 contain none of the words virtual, crypto, digital or bitcoin. Whether an exchange's hosted account is a custodial account at a foreign financial institution is therefore a question the text leaves to inference. It turns on whether the exchange "holds financial assets for the account of others as a substantial part of its business" and whether a coin is a "financial instrument, contract, or investment" or a "commodity". The documents checked do not answer either. A person could reasonably read an offshore exchange that takes customer deposits and holds coins in custody as a foreign financial institution, and another person could reasonably hold the opposite view. This article does not choose.
The IRS question-and-answer page does answer neighbouring questions, and the answers are useful by analogy though not directly on point. "Foreign currency is not a specified foreign financial asset and is not reportable on Form 8938" when held directly rather than in an account. Directly held precious metals such as gold are not specified foreign financial assets either, and neither are directly held collectibles. The IRS comparison table gives the same No for foreign currency and precious metals held directly. Those answers show how the IRS treated assets that sit outside an account, but they say nothing about digital assets, and the page adds that its listed examples "do not comprise an exclusive list of assets required to be reported".
Case 1: A Crypto-Only Account at a Foreign Exchange
The first case is the one most readers have. Maya is unmarried and lives in the United States. She holds only coins at an exchange based abroad. The account has never held any other asset, and its value was $41,000 on December 31 after reaching $63,000 in the spring. These are hypothetical figures.
| Test | Figure | Result |
|---|---|---|
| FBAR aggregate threshold | $10,000 | The $63,000 peak is $53,000 over it, but Notice 2020-2 says the account is not reportable |
| Form 8938, last day of year | More than $50,000 | $41,000 is $9,000 under it |
| Form 8938, any time in year | More than $75,000 | $63,000 is $12,000 under it |
Hypothetical case. Thresholds from the Instructions for Form 8938 (Rev. November 2021) and the IRS FBAR page.
The FBAR answer comes from the notice: a foreign account holding only virtual currency is "not reportable on the FBAR". The peak balance being well over $10,000 does not matter, because the account is outside the reportable categories in the first place. If the account ever held a fiat balance, even briefly, the parenthetical in the notice (an account that "holds reportable assets besides virtual currency") would need a second look.
The Form 8938 answer needs no classification at all in this version of the case. Even if the account were counted in full, $41,000 is not more than $50,000 on December 31, and the $63,000 peak is not more than $75,000. Neither alternative is met, so the open question about foreign exchanges never has to be answered.
It does if the numbers move. Suppose the peak had been $80,000 instead of $63,000. That is $5,000 more than $75,000, and the any-time test is met if the account counts as a specified foreign financial asset. At that point the answer depends on the unresolved question: whether this exchange is a foreign financial institution and its hosted account a custodial account. A filer in that spot has a judgment to make, with a possible $10,000 penalty for failing to file a required Form 8938 on one side and a filing that may not have been required on the other. The documents checked do not tell the filer which side the line is on.
Case 2: A Hardware Wallet and a Small Foreign Bank Account
Daniel and Priya are married, file a joint return and live in the United States. They keep most of their coins in a hardware wallet, valued at $188,000 on December 31 and $240,000 at its high. They also keep a bank account abroad, from an earlier posting overseas, that held $8,400 on December 31 and $9,200 at its high. Assume both highs fell on the same day, which is the least favourable assumption for them. These figures are hypothetical.
| Test | Threshold | Bank account alone | Bank account plus wallet |
|---|---|---|---|
| FBAR aggregate | More than $10,000 at any time | $9,200, which is $800 under | No institution maintains the wallet, so the account test has nothing to apply to |
| Form 8938, last day of year | More than $100,000 | $8,400, under | $196,400, which is $96,400 over |
| Form 8938, any time in year | More than $150,000 | $9,200, under | $249,200, which is $99,200 over |
Hypothetical case. Joint return, living in the United States.
The bank account is simple. At $9,200 it falls $800 short of the FBAR's $10,000 aggregate, so no FBAR is due for the year on the account alone, and it is far under both Form 8938 lines for a joint filer. A foreign bank account that does not require an FBAR can still change another answer. Schedule B (Form 1040), Part III, line 7a, Question 1, asks whether, at any time during the year, you "had a financial interest in or signature authority over a financial account (such as a bank account, securities account, or brokerage account) located in a foreign country". The 2025 Instructions for Schedule B say: "Check the 'Yes' box even if you aren't required to file FinCEN Form 114." So the couple answer Yes to Question 1 and No to Question 2, which asks whether they are required to file FinCEN Form 114.
The wallet is the real question, and it is the one the documents do not reach. A hardware wallet is not an account with a bank, a securities firm or any other person that maintains it, and each category in 31 CFR 1010.350(c) is defined by the person holding the account, so the FBAR test has nothing to attach to. For Form 8938 the instructions' two groups also fit awkwardly. A self-custody wallet is not "a financial account maintained by a foreign financial institution", because there is no institution. Nor is it clearly one of the listed non-account assets: a native coin has no issuer that is not a U.S. person and no counterparty, in the sense that stock, a bond or a swap does. The IRS's own answers on directly held foreign currency and gold point toward No for assets kept outside any account.
That is a reading of the text, not a statement the IRS has made. The Form 8938 documents do not say what to do with a wallet, and the IRS describes its own list of examples as non-exclusive. The last column of the table shows what is at stake if the reading were wrong: $196,400 and $249,200 would each be over the joint-return lines. Nor do the documents say where a wallet is located, or whether a wallet has a location at all.
Case 3: A Foreign Bank Account Holding Fiat and Coins
Chen is an unmarried U.S. citizen. The account is at a licensed bank abroad that holds cash deposits and also provides custody of coins on the bank's platform. It holds $6,000 in cash all year. The coins in it were worth $45,000 on December 31 and $76,000 at their high. The account therefore stood at $51,000 on December 31 and $82,000 at its high, taking the cash and coin highs to coincide. These figures are hypothetical.
This case differs from Case 1 in one respect that matters for both forms: the institution is a bank, and the account is a bank account in the ordinary sense, with a cash balance. That brings the notice's parenthetical into play.
| Test | Threshold | Result |
|---|---|---|
| FBAR, if only the cash is counted | More than $10,000 | $6,000, which is $4,000 under |
| FBAR, if the whole account is counted | More than $10,000 | $82,000, which is $72,000 over (8.2 times the threshold) |
| Form 8938, unmarried and living in the United States, last day | More than $50,000 | $51,000, which is $1,000 over |
| Form 8938, unmarried and living in the United States, any time | More than $75,000 | $82,000, which is $7,000 over |
| Form 8938, unmarried and living abroad, last day | More than $200,000 | $51,000, which is $149,000 under |
| Form 8938, unmarried and living abroad, any time | More than $300,000 | $82,000, which is $218,000 under |
Hypothetical case. Cash $6,000 throughout; coins $45,000 on December 31 and $76,000 at the high.
The FBAR. Because the institution is a bank and the account holds cash, it is a bank account under 31 CFR 1010.350(c)(1), and so it falls within the notice's own exception for an account that "holds reportable assets besides virtual currency". What the notice and Publication 5569 do not say is whether the coin balance counts toward the $10,000 aggregate or toward the maximum value reported. Publication 5569 defines maximum value as "a reasonable approximation of the greatest value of currency and non-monetary assets in the account during the calendar year". That wording, "non-monetary assets in the account", is the closest text, and on its face it points toward counting the whole account, which makes the answer $82,000 and the $10,000 line clearly crossed. But it does not mention virtual currency, so it cannot be treated as an answer to the virtual currency question. If only the cash counted, the account would sit $4,000 under the line and no report would be due. The two readings produce opposite filing results from the same statement, which is why this case belongs in the open list.
Form 8938. Here residence decides it, and the classification question from Case 1 does not arise because the account is plainly a deposit or custodial account at a foreign institution. For a filer who lives in the United States, the account is a specified foreign financial asset, and $51,000 is $1,000 over the year-end line while the $82,000 high is $7,000 over the any-time line, so Form 8938 is required. For the same account held by a U.S. citizen who meets a presence abroad test, none of the lines is close: $51,000 is $149,000 under the $200,000 year-end line and $82,000 is $218,000 under the $300,000 any-time line. The account is identical, and only the filer's residence changes the result. Under the instructions the account is reported at its maximum value, and the coins inside it are not reported separately, since "if you have an interest in a financial account that holds specified foreign financial assets, you do not have to report the assets held in the account".
Schedule B. A foreign bank account is a "financial account located in a foreign country", so Question 1 is a Yes whatever happens on the FBAR.
An exchange that holds some fiat balances raises a harder version of this case. Whether it is an institution "in the business of accepting deposits as a financial agency" under 1010.350(c)(3)(i), or a person "engaged in the business of banking", is a question about that exchange's activities. It is not settled by anything in the notice, so the hybrid exception cannot be assumed to apply to every exchange that lets users hold dollars.
The Form 1040 Question and Schedule B Line 7a
The Form 1040 digital asset question, in the 2025 form, reads: "At any time during 2025, did you: (a) receive (as a reward, award, or payment for property or services); or (b) sell, exchange, or otherwise dispose of a digital asset (or a financial interest in a digital asset)?" The draft 2026 form carries the same question with the year changed to 2026. The 2025 Instructions for Form 1040 say to check Yes for activities such as receiving digital assets as payment, as a reward or award, from mining, staking or a hard fork, disposing of one in exchange for property or services or for another digital asset, or selling one. Our table of 36 everyday situations for the Form 1040 question maps each case against those same two lists.
The instructions also list what, alone, "generally" does not require a Yes: "Holding a digital asset in a wallet or account"; "Transferring a digital asset from one wallet or account you own or control to another wallet or account that you own or control"; and "Purchasing digital assets using U.S. or other real currency, including through the use of electronic platforms such as PayPal and Venmo". A financial interest in a digital asset, per the instructions, exists if you "are the owner of record of a digital asset, or have an ownership stake in an account that holds one or more digital assets, including the rights and obligations to acquire a financial interest, or you own a wallet that holds digital assets".
Three points tie this question to the others.
The location of the asset is irrelevant to the answer. For Maya, for Daniel and Priya, and for Chen, the answer turns on what they did during the year, as it would for someone whose coins sit at a U.S. exchange. A sale on a foreign exchange is a disposal. A transfer between the foreign exchange account and the hardware wallet, with both owned by the same person, is not one on its own.
A Yes does not stand in for either foreign form, and a No does not exempt a filer from them. A person who only held coins on a foreign exchange all year, and bought them with dollars, can answer No to the digital asset question and still have to consider Form 8938 and, in a hybrid case, the FBAR.
Schedule B line 7a asks a separate foreign-account question, and in one respect it is broader than the FBAR, since it is answered Yes even where no FBAR is due. Its instructions say a financial account "includes, but isn't limited to, a securities, brokerage, savings, demand, checking, deposit, time deposit, or other account maintained with a financial institution (or other person performing the services of a financial institution)". The 2025 Schedule B instructions do not mention digital assets, virtual currency or crypto, so whether a coin-only exchange account triggers Question 1 is a fourth open point. The Form 1040 instructions send filers with foreign financial assets to Form 8938, with the line "If you had foreign financial assets in 2025, you may have to file Form 8938".
Penalties and Records
The IRS FBAR page does not state penalty amounts. It says: "Civil FBAR penalty maximums in Title 31 of the United States Code are adjusted annually for inflation." The amounts therefore come from the statute and the Treasury's adjustment table.
For the FBAR, 31 U.S.C. 5321(a)(5) (2024 edition, from govinfo) sets the structure. A non-willful penalty "shall not exceed $10,000". A reasonable cause exception applies where "(I) such violation was due to reasonable cause, and (II) the amount of the transaction or the balance in the account at the time of the transaction was properly reported". For willful violations, the maximum rises to "the greater of (I) $100,000, or (II) 50 percent of the amount determined under subparagraph (D)", and the reasonable cause exception does not apply. For a failure to report an account, subparagraph (D) is the balance in the account at the time of the violation. Section 5321(b)(1) lets the Secretary assess the penalty at any time before the end of the six-year period beginning on the date of the transaction.
The statutory figures are not the current ones. The penalty table in 31 CFR 1010.821, current through October 30, 2026 and last amended January 17, 2025, lists the adjusted maximums for penalties assessed on or after January 17, 2025: $16,536 against the $10,000 non-willful figure in 5321(a)(5)(B)(i), and $165,353 against the $100,000 willful figure in 5321(a)(5)(C)(i)(I). In Case 3, if the whole $82,000 account counted, the alternative of 50 percent of the balance would be $41,000, which is less than the dollar figure, so the dollar figure would be the larger. This is the ceiling the rules set and not a prediction of any penalty.
For Form 8938, the instructions state a failure-to-file penalty of $10,000. If the form is still not filed within 90 days after the IRS mails a notice of failure to file, a further $10,000 applies for each 30-day period or part of one, up to $50,000 more, which is five periods; the IRS comparison page gives the combined maximum as $60,000. The instructions also describe a 40 percent penalty on an underpayment attributable to an undisclosed specified foreign financial asset, a reasonable cause exception that the filer "must affirmatively show", and a statute of limitations that "may remain open for all or a part of your income tax return until 3 years after the date on which you file Form 8938". A foreign law that would punish disclosure is not reasonable cause.
Records matter for the first two cases as much as the third. The IRS FBAR page says that for each account you must report, you must keep the name on the account, the account number, the name and address of the foreign bank, the type of account and the maximum value during the year, generally for five years from the due date of the FBAR. The Form 8938 instructions let a filer rely on periodic account statements for maximum value. An exchange that issues only transaction histories and no statements leaves the filer to reconstruct the maximum value from a price history. Neither the Form 8938 instructions nor Publication 5569 says which price source is acceptable for a coin, and that is another reason to keep your own dated record.
Four Points the Documents Leave Open
These are the places where the documents checked stop short, stated plainly so that nothing in this article is read as covering them.
A fifth is the one every online exchange raises: the FBAR asks where an account is "located", which the Schedule B instructions put as "physically located outside of the United States". The documents give no rule for an exchange with no physical branch.
None of the four is settled by the October 5, 2026 FinCEN withdrawals, which concerned financial institutions' recordkeeping and reporting on transactions and not account holders' own reports.
Gathering What a Preparer Will Ask For
The questions above are for a tax professional who handles foreign reporting, and it saves time to arrive with the facts that decide them. Start with the institution: its legal name, the country where it is licensed, whether it holds any fiat balance for you, and whether its terms describe it as a bank, a broker or a custodian. Then the account: the account number, the dates it was open, the largest balance it reached in the year in both the account's currency and U.S. dollars, and the balance on December 31. Add every deposit, withdrawal and transfer to your own wallets, with the date, because those dates help establish the maximum value. Note who is named on the account, and whether a spouse or an entity also has an interest. For self-custody coins, list each wallet, what it holds, and when coins moved in or out. Then keep a short written record of how each figure was valued, with the price source, since the Form 8938 instructions tell a filer to rely on periodic statements only where they fairly reflect the maximum value.
For the broader U.S. rules on what is taxable and how basis works, the U.S. crypto tax guide covers the income tax side, Form 1099-DA covers what U.S. brokers now report, and the guide to per-wallet cost basis covers how lots are tracked across wallets. If you are weighing where to keep coins, moving crypto from an exchange to your own wallet and what happens to customer crypto if an exchange fails cover the custody side, and checking whether a platform is registered covers one way to tell what kind of institution you are dealing with. The full set is on the crypto taxes hub.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to file an FBAR if my only foreign account is a crypto exchange?
Not on the current rules, if the account holds only virtual currency. FinCEN Notice 2020-2 says "at this time, a foreign account holding virtual currency is not reportable on the FBAR (unless it is a reportable account under 31 C.F.R. 1010.350 because it holds reportable assets besides virtual currency)". If the account also holds cash or other reportable assets, the exception applies. The notice is a statement of current regulations and of FinCEN's intent to propose a change.
Has FinCEN finalized the rule that would add crypto to the FBAR?
No final rule appears in the eCFR, which is current through October 30, 2026, and no proposed rule appears in the Federal Register documents checked. The notice from December 31, 2020 said FinCEN "intends to propose" the amendment. The newest sources checked, the October 6, 2026 Federal Register withdrawals and the IRS digital assets page reviewed September 2, 2026, do not change that. The October 2026 withdrawals concerned two other proposals and do not mention the FBAR.
Does Form 8938 require me to report crypto?
The documents do not say. The Form 8938, its instructions, the IRS question-and-answer page and the comparison table never mention virtual currency, digital assets or crypto. The form covers financial accounts maintained by foreign financial institutions and certain foreign non-account assets. Whether a given exchange account or wallet falls within those terms is open, and the form applies only once the value passes the threshold for your filing status and residence.
What are the Form 8938 thresholds?
For an unmarried filer living in the United States, more than $50,000 on the last day of the tax year or more than $75,000 at any time during the year. For a married couple filing jointly in the United States, more than $100,000 or more than $150,000. For an unmarried filer living abroad, more than $200,000 or more than $300,000. For a married couple filing jointly living abroad, more than $400,000 or more than $600,000.
If I answer Yes to the Form 1040 digital asset question, does that mean I have to file Form 8938 or an FBAR?
No. The question asks whether you received or disposed of a digital asset during the year. It does not ask where anything is held and has no dollar threshold. Each foreign filing has its own test, and the digital asset answer is neither a trigger for them nor a substitute.
Do I answer Yes on Schedule B line 7a for a foreign exchange account?
For a foreign bank or brokerage account, yes. Question 1 asks about a financial account located in a foreign country, and the instructions say to check Yes even if you are not required to file FinCEN Form 114. For a coin-only exchange account, the instructions do not discuss crypto, so the answer depends on whether the exchange is treated as a financial institution.
Is a hardware wallet that I keep abroad a foreign financial account?
None of the documents checked says so. The FBAR covers accounts maintained with a financial institution, and a self-custody wallet has no institution. The Form 8938 documents list accounts at foreign financial institutions and certain foreign non-account assets, and do not name wallets.
Can I be penalized if I guessed wrong in good faith?
Both regimes have a reasonable cause exception, with different conditions. For the FBAR, the statute requires that the violation be due to reasonable cause and that the balance be properly reported, and it does not apply to willful violations. For Form 8938, the instructions say you "must affirmatively show the facts that support a reasonable cause claim". Whether a particular position qualifies is a facts-and-circumstances question for a tax professional.
Educational research only. Nothing here is tax, legal or investment advice, and nothing here tells any reader whether they must file any form. Reporting duties turn on facts that no article can see, including residence, filing status, entity structure and the exact terms of an account. Thresholds and penalty figures are those published by the IRS, FinCEN and the eCFR on the dates shown; confirm current figures and your own position with a qualified tax professional before filing.
Sources
Primary documents, market context, and methodology references behind this article.
Listed on FinCEN's FBAR page as dated 12/31/2020. Full operative text quoted. Checked November 3, 2026.
Still lists the virtual currency notice as an FBAR item. Checked November 3, 2026.
Text current through October 30, 2026; source note ends at 76 FR 37000 (June 24, 2011). Checked November 3, 2026.
Adjusted maximums for penalties assessed on or after January 17, 2025. Current through October 30, 2026. Checked November 3, 2026.
Civil penalty structure for violations of section 5314, reasonable cause exception, six-year assessment period. Checked November 3, 2026.
$10,000 aggregate threshold, due dates, records, penalties statement. Page reviewed July 30, 2026. Checked November 3, 2026.